Bagel Packages


Our hand-rolled, extra large NY bagels are fresh, and use only the finest all-natural ingredients with no preservatives and no bromates
  • Hand-rolled for you in New York City
  • Free Overnight Shipping
  • 3 extra bagels with each dozen ordered
  • Extra large size - absolutely no preservatives
  • Shipped in a white, branded New Yorker giftbox
  • Add an optional free gift message

Available NY Bagel Assortments:

Each assortment includes 3 sleeves of 5 hand-rolled bagels - that's 3 free with each order!
Choose from our 5 curated packages, or create your own by selecting the Custom line. 
Assortment Name Details
Broadway bagels
  • 5 Cranberry Energy
  • 5 Quinoa Multigrain
  • 5 Whole Wheat

$44
+ Free Overnight shipping

Canarsie bagels
  • 5 Poppy
  • 5 Pumpernickel
  • 5 Marble Rye (new!)

$42
+ Free Overnight shipping

Pelham bagels
  • 5 Plain
  • 5 Sesame
  • 5 Cinnamon Raisin

$39.50
+ Free Overnight shipping

Rockaway bagels
  • 5 Everything
  • 5 Jalapeño Pepper
  • 5 Kalamata Olive (new!)

$42
+ Free Overnight shipping

 Staten Island bagels
  • 5 Apple Pie (new!)
  • 5 Blueberry
  • 5 French Toast

$44
+ Free Overnight shipping

custom new york bagels


Build your own!

You select 3 flavors from our 16 bagel varieties. Build your own package.

$45
+ Free Overnight shipping



Not quite ready to order?

It’s cool... Use the "Stay Fresh" area below  to sign up for our email and get the latest NY Bagel news and specials.
We email only once or twice a month!
Also be sure to follow us on Facebook and Twitter.